BajaNomad

Cultural differences

jrbaja - 1-11-2005 at 02:19 PM

This was explained to me by my neighbors a couple days ago.
Mexicanos place life in this order.
1. Family
2. Patriotism
3. Money

They see the gringos placing their priorities in this order.
1. Money
2. Patriotism
3. Family

Let's see what kind of concoction this kind of observation stirs up from the
m-asses:lol:

Packoderm - 1-11-2005 at 03:22 PM

When a people place liberty as #1, the rest takes care of itself as you see in the U.S. Just take care of the one big piece, and the rest of the puzzle falls into place. Being what is considered a soul-less country is a luxury that many people in many countries would love to be able to emulate.

Jr, I have noticed that you have a keen interest in this particular segment of sociology. Have you considered majoring in the subject in a university?

Dave - 1-11-2005 at 04:19 PM

All, except dysfuctional people, place the welfare of family above all else. Only fatalists and/or socialists fail to understand that to adequately PROVIDE for the welfare of the family, money is needed.

I suspect that in any list, family and money would go hand in hand.

I doubt that your neighbors have intimate knowledge of the lives of ALL or even MOST Mexicanos and Americanos. As such, their opinions are just like....well, you know...








[Edited on 1-11-2005 by Dave]

Dave - 1-11-2005 at 04:25 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Dave their opinions are just like....well, you know...
[Edited on 1-11-2005 by Dave]


I would also add.....insulting

Braulio - 1-11-2005 at 05:33 PM

JR - might I ask what language your neighbor used to communicate to you these perlas of sabidur?a?

I know it couldn't have been spanish because on the few occasions you've used spanish on these forums you've shown that you don't have even the most rudimentary understanding of it.

Having said that, there are some cultural difference - and there might even be some truth in the lists. Unfortunately you're incapable of being the messenger here.

Kind of frustrating ain't it.

Why not do some serious study on the spanish language first - and then you can be the official nomad "window to the mexican mind".

Oso - 1-11-2005 at 07:04 PM

Complete and utter bullchit.

It took someone to explain this to you?

FrankO - 1-11-2005 at 08:47 PM

Nothing like a little cultural ignorance. It's funny, but I never categorize my friends by nationality, or they me. My TRUE friends always categorize family first. People will tell themselves many things to justify their prejudices.
I have it this way:
1: Family and friends on the same level( just cuz they're family doesn't mean they're a friend).
2: Loyalty
3: Life enriching experiences (FUN!)
4: Family and friends


[Edited on 1-12-2005 by FrankO]

Politicians...

Capt. George - 1-11-2005 at 09:12 PM

Mexicano or Norte Americano, in this order:

1: Money

2. Money

3. Money

adios vikingo

Actually guys

jrbaja - 1-12-2005 at 09:11 AM

Even I could understand that much Spanish. And to say that what they were telling me is complete and utter bullchit, is complete and utter bullchit!
And, I didnt say it included everyone and every family, but from what I have experienced and seen in many parts of the u.s. and Mexico, it really is a pretty accurate summarization.
How do you think all those divorces in the u.s. affect family morals? Makes for some pretty strong family values eh .:lol:
And then when the parents die, the brothers, sisters and family members are attorneys favorite folks as it generally means major battles amongst each other for the money.
Rightio gringo patriots, you are truly a special breed to ignore whats really going on there.:lol:

Braulio - 1-12-2005 at 09:28 AM

Vaya, vaya, vaya - aren't we the quisquilloso ones.

Roberto - 1-12-2005 at 09:35 AM

JR, you are stuck in some kind of a warp. Not a time warp, more like a closed-mind warp. You just proved that with your comments on Braulio and Oso. Do you have any idea who these guys are and how they fit into the picture of Mexicans and Americans? You probably figure these are guys that know only gringo enclaves, right? :lol::lol::lol:

And by the way, how many of those free Baja Search and Rescue directories did you finally distribute to the contributors?

Dare I guess?

Can't you find some other way to think highly of yourself besides feeling superior to others? :O

fools

yankeeirishman - 1-12-2005 at 09:43 AM

All Politicians are hoars, no matter where you live! As far as the U.S. "family" values go.... my kids call me? their Hero"! I am sure that there are a lot of the same as my family, and NOT yours! But now...you know I need need money to feed these critters of mine. Without money...I am the fool of fools to allow my family go without a decent home, food, clothes, and mostly an education! You on the other hand...perhaps you need to open your eyes! Fool!

[Edited on 1-12-2005 by yankeeirishman]

I was repeating what was told to me

jrbaja - 1-12-2005 at 10:06 AM

and the same old riff raff has to turn it into an argument. Or shall I say bull ya base as I mentioned in the first posting.
I know Oso and Braulio are fluent in Spanish and I am not. So friggen what, Im trying to learn and not embarrased to try.
Most of my friends are Mexican and not ones who live in the border towns where things are a little different than the rest of Mexico.
For me to post what was told to me and then have people , do you know who I am
:lol::lol::lol:, attack and say that it wasnt said is very P-nche gringo like in my books.
Perhaps San Luis is a great example of what most Mexicans think but I seriously doubt it considering the location.
I think you guys are better off with the insight of the coop groupers when it comes to spending time and knowing areas of Baja besides the border towns and gringo enclaves which these guys all live in.
Rosarito, hahahahahahaha

A subject of particular interest to me...

Herb - 1-12-2005 at 10:27 AM

and one that I have studied at the university (both US and Mexican)...

I would be surprised to see patriotism make the top 3 in most Mexicans' view of the world. At least in the way that we view patriotism in the US. We tend to associate patriotism with loyalty and support for our government whereas I believe Mexican patriotism is focused more on national pride and thus many Mexicans consider themselves patriotic even while having near absolute contempt for the government.

Dave's assertion that pursuit of money=concern for family is not entirely accurate either. That often is the initial motivation but it quickly becomes a lie that people tell themselves. In my professional world, I see people all the time working ridiculous hours to "get ahead" telling themselves that "I'm doing it for my family" even though that family has become a group of people they barely know and never see or actually talk to because they are always at work. I used to be one of those people. All studies have shown that as our national collective wealth increases, the family structure breaks down more. The same thing appears to be happening in places like Mexico as well. The fact is that it takes very little money to provide the basics for our families' existence (food, shelter, etc) The other things that we strive to earn more money for to provide for them to make their lives "easier" do not necessarily make their lives "better." Educational opportunities may be one of few exceptions.

I do not believe you can determine an individual's value system based on their nationality. I DO believe that you will find more people who genuinely have a valule system that places family first south of the border than you will north of the border (and sociological research would suggest the same.)

I do not believe, however, that it is due to any particular sense of altruism inherited through Native American, Spanish or Mestizo genes. In fact, I believe the diferences stem from the fact that all people are inherently selfish.

Mike H. hit the nail on the head in a post a while ago when he theorized on why a rural Mexican rancher in a remote part of Baja is more likely to help someone in need. He mentioned that the guy would not likely see himself as having done anything special. That it is just what is necessary to survive in a world that has more harsh natural challenges. You see, that guy and anyone around him is most likely going to need the assistance of others at some point in his life to survive himself so that behavior becomes ingrained as a way of life in his world.

I believe we see the same thing with the family unit. Historically, the family unit was a key enabler helping people survive and even thrive in a world of man vs. his environment. Having a family meant more resources available to thwart the calmaties that life can throw our way.

As our world becomes less primitive, through technological advances and wealth accumulation, our families become less important or even irrelevant to our survival. In fact they can even become impediments to our prusuits. We begin to focus on wants and desires once survival has become a given.

The even more rapid breakdown of the family in poorer US communities over the last 70 years further demonstrates this. In a welfare society, a single poor working man and a single mother on welfare are much better off financially than a family with a single working poor father in the home, especially if the mother cannot (or will not) indentify the father.

That is why I, like JR, prefer spending as much time as possible in places where families and community are still more needed, and thus, more appreciated and more highly valued. Sadly, it won't stay that way for long as it will soon be replaced by what we call progress!

Finally, Capt George: I almost agree although I would actually replace money with power. For most politicians I've met, power is the source of climax for them. Money is just the aphrodisiac and foreplay to make it possible...:o

bajajudy - 1-12-2005 at 11:07 AM

I am reminded of a quote from one of the Traveler's Tales of Mexico

"Americans wonder why Mexicans treats their dogs so poorly.
Mexicans wonder why Americans treat their children so poorly."

I dont sanction either behavior but it does point to some pretty obvious cultural differences.

That said, I wouldn't live anywhere else right now!

Worshipping false Gods

Mavica - 1-12-2005 at 02:41 PM

Count me among the disbelievers of the sermon that Mexican family values are somehow superior to those of families in the US or Canada. We each define and interpret situations using our own individual life experiences and observations as guideposts. Family life in Mexico is dysfunctional. It might not be more dysfunctional than family units in other countries but it's not in better shape. People are people, only the scene where life's being acted out changes.


'Ni heolas go haontios'

RandyMacSC/SO - 1-12-2005 at 03:26 PM


In English from Ol' Irish (Gaelic):
There is no knowledge without unity; or less accurate: 'You don't know a person until you live with them' :)

RandyMac

JESSE - 1-12-2005 at 03:47 PM

The reality is that Mexican society is very diverse, depending on the area of Mexico you go to, i think right now most Mexicans give money the top priority, and thus the reason why this nation is in such poor shape.




Too Weird

RandyMacSC/SO - 1-12-2005 at 05:26 PM

A few nights ago I started getting this feeling of anxiousness, a heavy heart or a sense of dread, and couldn't sleep. Thought I was close to having the big jammer, but the Doc says everything's okay. Aching back, arms, chest was tight etc, so I decided to go for a brisk walk before I hit the hay. Felt much better, went back to sleep and had an extremely vivid reoccurring dream.

Upon waking, I decided to start again on JR's logo. I felt good. It was one of the many things weighing on my noodle, but not the most weighty item. An important line item. But that's the least concern of my feelings as of late. The logo has been fun to take care of (okay it's not finished, but it appears to be on the right track)-- especially since the JR is pleased as punch. Delivering on a promise is important.. Important yes, but it's not my excuse for the dreadful feelings. Perhaps it's too much BBC and Tsunami stuff? So I have tuned it out, to chill a bit.

Of yeh! The DREAM, and dread sh77.
There is something out there that I can't quite put a handle on? Is it the life force of so many people being squelched out? Perhaps? Maybe it's my angst towards falling prey to days of old?

THE DREAM
The dream was about impending doom, greed, society against society, the rat race of today's work environment, 80 -- 100 hours being demanded each week, but for 40 hour week pay -- no time to ponder why an ant is an ant, and seems to be so content at just being an ant.

The dream seemed to be in pure thought, but not in my regular native tonque dreams I'm used to having, but in ol' Gaelic or Old Irish. Like some ancient message fed into a blurry receiver.

I can't remember much Galeic, but I do remember my Gran used to speak to me in this way cool old language when I was young. She tossed out these profound sayings all the time, such that my friends would get mezmerized by the spoken words, even though they could hardly understand much of anything she said. I'd do my best translation, and we'd chant them back as best we could the whole time we were playing out in the back forty. Come to think of it. At one time it was full of trees and bush and always full of kids. Now not one kid plays there, unless it's organized soccer. It's a big green park now and kids aren't allowed to explore. All the cool things were cleared away. Kind of like it's life force has been zapped. Go figure.

My Gran used to always tell me: 'EEEh Raaaandaaall, de rhut' of all evil is not de quest ah money, but da jealousy'. Understand de jealousy my youngin, an' live da life as it was meant ta be.'

Not being one to disregard it as random gibberish, I have tried to interpret this strange, but interesting experience.

I just recently went back to the software industry. Not because I wanted to, but it's what I know best, or so I believe. Why? A friend needs some help and called me just before I was to head off to the Baja, and she's been a real good friend to me, especially when I needed a true friend, and someone to trust, and I won't let her down in her time of need.

I agreed to only go back to this often life crippling, greed driven industry, but on my strict terms. I will work 40 hours a week -- for 40 hours pay. Screw all the stock options and crap. I won't bite or be driven by the 'BFGF' hook again. (BIG F----ing Greed Factor).

Pay me for what I deliver in those 40 hours, no more, no less. It's not going to be my whole life, just a small percentage of my life. I have other plans, and dying at a desk, delivering over and above a pile of unrealistic demands from some management cakehole is not my idea of living the last days of my precious life, and, nor is it my absolute duty to do so. The team of software engineers I manage will take walks, hike in the Alps, when necessary, and they'll have a family life, and we'll deliver on all our promises. We won't get sucked into the black hole. We'll put out world class software solutions to better people's lives.

I'm extremely excited about the job, but I do have to admit that I have a feeling of making a mistake. Probably why I have been feeling anxious lately. Not for helping a friend, but for jumping back into the digital high tech rat race. Talk about a greedy cutthroat dog eat dog soul sucking industry!!! I've been there hook line and sinker. I was extremely driven 16 years ago, made a ton, spent a ton, gave away a ton, wazzed away a bus load on glittzy digs, frivolous crap, big parties, dingy bars etc. You get the drift. I never seemed to be happy.

I was able to help my family and some friends and that gave me good piece of mind. BUT! Five years ago I decided to walk away from it all. A few people felt I deserved the break, but it did wazz many many people off. It's amazing what people will expect out of one person, and what they'll say behind your back, but few people have the balls to cut straight to it. Such as this: Hey Mac, I'm a greedy sack of crap, and you owe me. I found out all about who my friends are since that day. Take one hand, fold back 2 or 3 fingers, and the true one(s) are few and far between.

To make a longin' shorter.

Five years ago at a tender age of 42, I packed it all in, bought a little motorhome, little 4x4 and went on my merry way to Yucatan Mexico. I had felt like I had just started life (again), and I learned more than I ever could in any business, or social setting that the previous 16 years of the often exciting, but life mangling high tech arena could throw at me. A few years later it was the Baja.

Too pinch it off. THE DREAMTIME: Don't fall back into the same old rut and turn into a sack of *&$% again. If so, I deserve it. Deliver on your promises, but remember to live.

When I finish my task at hand, I'm headed to the Baja. No motorhome, no fancy digs. I plan to stick to my promise of not getting caught up in the rat race, crazy life sucking people issues, mud slinging, gringo crap this, gringo crap that, you name it. I plan to stay away from it all. And if that means going aboriginal, or turning part mountain man, so be it.

The Quest: GIve all my possessions away, help needy people, get closer to nature and befriend that ant. Maybe we'll learn some life skills from each other, and what it takes to be truly happy.

RandyMac
Ramblings of a Mad Man. :lol:


[Edited on 1-13-2005 by RandyMac]

Bajadtodebone - 1-12-2005 at 05:30 PM

Being new to this forum it will take me awhile to aclimate myself to the ins and outs of what goes on here. Having said that, there are some things I hope I never get used to, one being the crap Americanos can cum up with in the name of one-upsmanship. There is a lot of truth mixed in with a lot of self-erving enuendo. I look forward to more of these "spirited" debates!! Just two observations if I may. I see litttle wrong with the priorities described in the opening post, regardless of the language they were spoken or how they were interpreted. I have found both lists to be fairly accurate. It is interesting, the issue of family values being discussed by a bunch of Californians. I left my native California precisely because of the on-going decline of family values and the lack of compassion for each other. Both of which I feel could be traced back to the pursuit of money. Which is why we now live in Tennessee and Baja. People in these two places (among others) have value systems which make them comfortable to be around. Now if we could just filter out all of those Americans/Californians who think they leave their baggage at the border from entering Baja and polluting the air as they pollute this forum. Just one other comment. The fact, as it was mentioned by Grover, that we attribute "patriotism" to the support of a government (read elected officials) is one of the biggest and most dangerous mistakes made by Americans and precisely why we are getting into the sad state we seem to entering. Patriotism IS love of Country, regardless of who is leading it. And it is precisely why the leadership must always be challenged on how and where it leads us.
Such acts are patriotic in its true condition.

God Bless You Randy Mac!!

Skeet/Loreto - 1-12-2005 at 05:43 PM

Mac and others on this Thread:

1. God
2.Family
3. Country

JR. You have still not learned from the Mountain People! I still think that you should go up in the Mountains for at least 6 months.Think{How can I learn Compassion from these good People?}

Mac. your story reminds me of many people I have met while involved in my Minestry of helping People find their way and improving their Lives. God has many ways of gettin peoples attention, sometimes Pain is used,You cannot run away from Life, we all must face it on a Daily Basis, from the Hobo in the Street to the President.
When I finally learned Compassion from some Mexicano Friends I became a new person with a Purpose in Life which lead me back to Christainity.
Faith Hope and Chairty

Skeet/Loreto

Pray or become Prey

Skeetster!! How are you my friend?

RandyMacSC/SO - 1-12-2005 at 07:07 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Skeet/Loreto
........
Pray or become Prey


Been spending a few hours at this Irish Galeic stuff for old times sake. My Gran always wanted me to learn the language. Perhaps I will one day. Brings back many beautiful childhood memories.

'Is nios congarach cunamh De na an doras' Pronounced as: 'Iss nee-us cone-gar-uck coo-nav djay naw on dur-as'

Translates to: 'Gods' Help is nearer than the door'.

-----
Skeet: Remember back when we first struck a chord with each other on Nomad back in Feb 2004? The formation of a friendship was kindled.

Spent some time at my cousins since that time, and it was as if it was all meant to be. A time to reconnect.

My cousin and his wife told me they used to be real party animals, and then 10 years ago they decided to make some life changes. When I visited, they asked me if I wanted to go to church on a Saturday afternoon for an hour. I was reluctant at first, and didn't know what to expect, but decided, 'Why not.'

On the way to the church I mentioned you Skeet, how our friendship began, and your suggestion that I might go to church. They asked what was holding me back. I won't get into the details of all that, but I will say this. It was a most enjoyable experience. And I started to reflect more about what is truly important in life.

Fun, laughter, happiness all around, and people were just happy to be in each others' presense.

I even sang. Imagine that? You should have seen my cousin's face and his wife's face. The Macster knew all the words. My cheeks got all rosey and I could carry a tune.

On the way home, they asked me of my thoughts. I just beamed and smiled all the way home and into the night. Had many a thought provoking conversations with my cousin Bruce after that. I stay in touch more now, and make it a point to focus more time for the little things that brings smiles to my heart. Never thought I would say that having beers with the boys isn't so important, but it isn't. Of course I visit my buds, but drink water instead. They understand that I have Type 2 diabeties, and they don't give me a hard time.

Even though I haven't gone to church since, (not much for being around lots of people) I do cherish the time between 4:00 and 5:00 on Saturdays, or the equivalent if I'm in another time zone. No matter where I am I find the time to reflect and pray. I don't have to physically be in Edmonton with my cousin, his wonderful wife, and their grandchildren to sing with the congregation of fine people.

I just need to remember to take a moment out and reflect, beam and smile during that time. I'm with them, they are in my toughts, and it feels good to me. So I'm not gonna question it.

Thus: 'Is nios congarach cunamh De na an doras'

God Bless You Skeetster. We'll meet one day my friend.

RandyMac


reminds me of this very important quote...

RandyMacSC/SO - 1-12-2005 at 08:04 PM

No matter what I think after reading some of the posts JR.

"I may disagree with what you have to say, but I shall defend to the death your right to say it."
Voltaire, (Attributed); originated in "The
Friends of Voltaire", 1906, by S. G. Tallentyre
(Evelyn Beatrice Hall)

RandyMac