BajaNomad

Cruz Roja??? For real or a scam

thebajarunner - 4-7-2007 at 07:24 PM

We all know the drill....
It seems to be a permanent fixture in Colonet, we even had them at the toll booths, southbound.
Sweet young ladies, with the Red X cans, and the stickers.

So, my question, is this really for the Cruz Roja? or for the collectors?? or for whatever??

Somehow, it just sometimes looks to be a bit much.

And yeah, my Ford windshield has more Red X's than bug splatters right now, sitting in my home garage.

Sharksbaja - 4-7-2007 at 09:14 PM

Scam. Ever see them at a disaster scene?:no:
They are cute tho. Funny, I guess my windshield is too high for roja splatters. :lol:

bancoduo - 4-7-2007 at 09:19 PM

You never know. I've been wondering about that for years. A good subject for Dateline.:lol:

woody with a view - 4-8-2007 at 07:00 AM

many, many years ago you could count on them stopping traffic in camalu. the rumor was if you were in an accident and they saw your window sticker (old school postage stamp size, not the current baseball sized) they'd help you first! glad i never had to put that rumor to the test.

what the hell, a few pesos never hurt anyone...

comitan - 4-8-2007 at 07:22 AM

If you get into an accident thats who will be there to help you medically, They will give you Emergency Medical care and transport you to the nearest hospital. They are all there is for these Emergencies and support themselves with donations. Otherwise these donations are going to a good cause!!!

jimgrms - 4-8-2007 at 07:35 AM

There are a couple of them males in white suits in colorado at a off ramp in highlands ranch and one in castle rock i kinda think they are scams

comitan - 4-8-2007 at 07:40 AM

Some of these people for donations are scammers, the guys in white outfits are mostly from a program called Cread which helps dopers and Most people I know don't donate to them because they believe your just buying them another joint or bottle.

fdt - 4-8-2007 at 09:44 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by Sharksbaja
Scam. Ever see them at a disaster scene?:no:
They are cute tho. Funny, I guess my windshield is too high for roja splatters. :lol:

Sorry but you are very mistaken, Cruz Roja is at every disaster scene, they were there for huricane john and they were there for Katrina, yes Cruz Roja Mexicana was in New Orleans.
As comitan sais they are the only ones that will come to you if God forbid you are ever in an accident. There is an anual collection that is going on right now and will end on the 15th. You can donate year round but it is a nationwide collection right now and guess what, if they were to ever pick you up you wont get a bill like in the US.
Now as for those people in white that you see at the border, I believe they are a scam, if you don't see a red cross it probably is a scam.
As for the story that they wont pick you up if there is no sicker thatis just an urban legend.
http://www.cruzrojamexicana.org.mx/

fdt - 4-8-2007 at 09:46 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by comitan
Some of these people for donations are scammers, the guys in white outfits are mostly from a program called Cread which helps dopers and Most people I know don't donate to them because they believe your just buying them another joint or bottle.

We give to PBS instead

Bajafun777 - 4-8-2007 at 10:01 AM

Well, like the rest of the Nomads that have traveled Baja over the years we have all seen wrecks. Now, the question is who do you see going to take the victims of these wrecks to medical care??? The answer is Cruz Roja as we have all seen them do so, right??? I have and I know others have also. I give to them as like others have posted here you never know and I want someone on the road that will come to my aide. Later---- bajafun777

Methinks some missed the point of the question

thebajarunner - 4-8-2007 at 10:55 AM

No one (I would hope) is questioning the legitimacy, nor the importance of the Red Cross here or the Cruz Roja in Baja.

My question, are those street characters legit, and does the money go to Cruz Roja?

And, if so, then howcome every town does not put up the blockade and collect funds.?

And yeah, I never pass one up, usually put in a 10 peso piece.

Sharksbaja - 4-8-2007 at 12:37 PM

What I am referring to is the donation itself. I have a hard time believing that the money they collect actually goes into the organization for legit purposes. That would be a switch from the norm.
I've never seen them at a wreck. Perhaps they were on their way.

If they actually use the money to help those in need then I stand corrected .
Yes, I give to them regardless of what they do.



[Edited on 4-8-2007 by Sharksbaja]

fdt - 4-8-2007 at 06:50 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by thebajarunner


are those street characters legit, and does the money go to Cruz Roja?

They are legit, and all are volunteers from either schols, clubs or organizations. Now, when they go to the bathroom and take theire collection can with them, maybe some take some taco money from the can :?::?:

Quote:
Originally posted by thebajarunner
And, if so, then howcome every town does not put up the blockade and collect funds.?



All towns do it, now there are delegations for Cruz Roja and maybe that is why some are permanent.
Every year we get envelopes from the school with each child so we can send in our donation.

fdt - 4-8-2007 at 07:05 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Sharksbaja
I have a hard time believing that the money they collect actually goes into the organization for legit purposes. That would be a switch from the norm.


They are very strict with the collection committee, very closely watched and audited, nationwide thing. Now as for every person delivering the full ammount, don't know that, it's a lot of volunteers.

Quote:
Originally posted by Sharksbaja
I've never seen them at a wreck. Perhaps they were on their way.


Could be, remember the vast distances between towns in Baja California.

I strongly believe that this is a very honorable and noble institution.
Theire slogan is "No one is so poor that can not help her and no one is so rich that can not need her"
Here in town you see them all day, every day.
saludos

Sorry! I just can't believe the comments about SCAMS

Baja Bernie - 4-8-2007 at 07:26 PM

I have been working with Cruz Rojas since about 1970's in Rosarito and they are NO scam and I have knowledge that this is one thing that the government would not allow scammers because they provide such an important service.
When I became involved it was because I found that their vehicles didn't even have any form of communications.....not their ambulances, lifeguard vehicles, or even the rigs (mostly old bread trucks) that provided clinics in the back country.
I asked the Chief if I could take medical supplies and old CB radios that were destined for distruction and give them to Cruz Rojas. We equiped all of their vehicles with communications and provided base stations. I took medical supply's to Rosarito for years..............Always made me very angry when I found that several of the major schools and hospitals in the states donated obsolete equipment that required electricity to run to Baja AND got tax credits when they knew that they could not be used...............

Okay! I am calm now..............anyone who does not have those 'stupid' stickers on their windshields is not...........to me..........a real Nomad..................yes Bajarunner I still consider you a friend but sometimes you amaze me............Your wonderful wife should be able to advise you.

Sorry! But I feel very strongly about this.

[Edited on 4-9-2007 by Baja Bernie]

thebajarunner - 4-8-2007 at 08:30 PM

Bernie, calm down,
what did you have for dinner???

My question is about the collectors, not about the agency.

It still looks sort of fishy to me, the way some of those towns (Colnet/Camalu) have permanent collectors, yet other towns never ever have them.

(and I do agree with Sharky- I have seen lots of wrecks in Baja, and never have seen the CR attending- saw a nasty one two weeks ago just a few miles north of Colnet- an EcoBus and a steel hauling semi- very ugly, no Cruz Roja)

And yeah, I washed my truck last week and still have four stickers on the windshield... ask Baja Vida... he is a bigger sissy than I when it comes to giving.

burro bob - 4-9-2007 at 08:42 AM

Here in San Felipe we have three different outfits that collect money at intersections. First are the CREAD guys, the ones in drug rehab. They don't collect at intersections very often.
The second group is a religious organization. They wear white suits and have a logo that includes a red cross. However it is a Christian cross not the red Plus sign the Red Cross uses. They are most often the ones out collecting at the intersections and I believe many of you confuse these people with the Red Cross collectors. I know nothing about them or how they use the money they collect. They do try to make the uneducated Gringo think they are Red Cross though.
Third there is the real Red Cross. They only collect one or two weekends a year. They are well organized and in much larger groups than the religious red crossers. They also put a small sticker on your window when you donate and they stop asking for donations when they see you have already given.
Quite frankly the Red Cross is one of the best groups to donate to in Mexico. The money is well used. This organization is well trusted and highly used here in San Felipe by the locals.
burro bob

Dave - 4-9-2007 at 10:13 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by Baja Bernie
I have been working with Cruz Rojas since about 1970's in Rosarito and they are NO scam and I have knowledge that this is one thing that the government would not allow scammers because they provide such an important service.


Locally there have been a few, one within the past year involving misappropriation of funds and a substitute ambulance scam.

The government should be ashamed that its citizens would have to depend on a charitable organization for one-on-one emergency care. And I doubt that given the opportunity, government officials wouldn't scam from the CR... They do everything else.

I support the Cruz Roja, mainly cause it's better than nothing...Barely. [I could tell you stories] ;D

And while I'm ranting: Why is it that funeral processions are afforded right of way and not ambulances?

Sharksbaja - 4-9-2007 at 11:39 AM

"And while I'm ranting: Why is it that funeral processions are afforded right of way and not ambulances?"

Dod?

Sharksbaja - 4-9-2007 at 11:40 AM

Sorry, that's "dead on departure"

shari - 4-9-2007 at 05:38 PM

In Guerrero Negro the Cruz roja is very active and legit...but sometimes those rascals in the nice white suits come...SCAM...but it's pretty obvious when the real RC is soliciting funds as they are there with their ambulances and well organized...but I have heard nasty rumors of them stealing stuff from accident sites so it's always good to leave someone if possible to guard your stuff...also the attending policia have been known to lift some goodies as well...so even though tough...take your valuables with you or have someone guard the vehicle.

Shari

Baja Bernie - 4-9-2007 at 07:43 PM

Good advice, but remember they just may be responsible for your survival on this earth! Then how important are those earthly things that might stick to their fingers..............I do wonders.