BajaNews - 12-18-2010 at 07:34 PM
http://www.sandiegoreader.com/news/2010/dec/08/yonder-riedel...
By Rene Peralta
Dec. 8, 2010
All buildings begin as ideas. Yet, not all have an aura to develop into a story of their own, a story uninhibited from the architect’s will and its
client’s desires. Like the houses we dwell in, some buildings become our first universe; as the French philosopher Gaston Bachelard mentioned, “a real
cosmos in every sense of the word.” Few buildings retain their literary sense and inspire a virtual travel through its space and materiality. But
there is a building in Tijuana that reflects the desires of three personalities — that through their will and faith they construct the blueprint of
not only a physical space but create a universe of emotions that even today resonates as you walk through its doors. This is the story of a doctor, a
nun, and three young architects who gave birth to architecture.
Tijuana’s Temporary Monument
The Riedel Medical Building (known today as Del Prado Medical Center) in Tijuana became transformed by spiritual will and a desire to create a
state-of-the art cardiology center, open to all who might need specialized care, despite their economic background. A building that today has become
one of the leading health centers in the city, yet it has been camouflaged by the rampant urbanization and obscured by a more recent and controversial
addition to its principal façade.
The creation of the medical center in 1963 was the effort of Maria Luisa Riedel Betancourt, a tijuanense from a prominent family who financed a small
private two-story hospital in what was considered the outskirts of the city, near the Agua Caliente racetrack and the silos of the local flour
company, El Rosal.
By the 1970s, the hospital became well known around the region for its outstanding medical care. Riedel Betancourt decided to expand the facilities
and build a center with medical offices for the doctors. Riedel Betancourt gave the task of designing the new wing to a member of her family, Livio
Santini, a young architect who helped form the first generation of architects who studied in Los Angeles at the newly created Southern California
Institute of Architecture (SCI-Arc). Santini invited Michael Rotondi (also part of that first generation) and Thom Mayne, principal of the firm
Morphosis and instrumental in forming the school.
During the late ’70s, Tijuana was going through radical urban changes — a new downtown was being built, and the manufacturing industry was becoming
the major economic sector of the city. The three architects, who were in their late 20s and early 30s, took on the task of designing the medical
center in a city that was to them a frontier.
Santini and Rotondi joined Thom Mayne and his firm Morphosis to design and build the medical center. Morphosis was then a young firm creating an
oeuvre via competitions and small commissions; their design process was known for its provocative drawings and minuscule, detailed models.
In 1977, the firm entered the medical center’s design into the Progressive Architecture Awards and was awarded a citation for the building. The jury
hailed the design for its elegance, articulation of spaces, and its sensitivity. One of the jurors, John Dinkeloo, saw it as a futuristic design and
mentioned, “It’ll never be built. It will take at least 20 years.” Yet, the architects began construction three years later, in 1980.
It’s a simple building separated into three functional areas and four floors above ground; the building is orientated west and sheathed in green glass
block. Constructing an elegantly designed building in Tijuana presented challenges for the young firm. Using local contractors, builders, and all
materials from Tijuana (except for some specialty hardware from the U.S.), the building was completed in 1983. After the completion of the new wing,
the medical center continued to be a premiere clinic in the region.
Coincidence Became Divine Providence
By the 1980s, one of Riedel Betancourt’s daughters, Patricia Aubanel, had become a cardiologist and returned from the United States to work again in
her native Tijuana. Aubanel had a desire to bring modern cardiology back to her country. After studying at Boston University, the University of
Massachusetts, and Harvard and specializing in interventional cardiology, she found it difficult to practice her specialty in her hometown due to the
lack of resources to do so. So, she began to work at Scripps Clinic in La Jolla.
In 1991, Aubanel embarked on a personal and professional journey that would lead her back to what she most desired: a specialized cardiology center in
Tijuana. During this time she met a Catholic nun by the name of Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu, who would become her spiritual guide. She was known to the rest
of the world as Mother Teresa of Calcutta. In Tijuana, Mother Teresa had founded three homes for the poor with her Missionaries of Charity
organization and during 1991 had returned to oversee the charity’s work with the city’s poor and elderly.
Aubanel was still working for Scripps Clinic and was making frequent trips to Tijuana, where she cared for patients at the medical center. It was a
late December morning of the same year when the doctor received a call from Tijuana’s Bishop Emilio Carlos Berlie Belauzarán, who told her that a
special friend was sick and needed a cardiologist to evaluate her condition when she came to visit. The bishop made it clear that he would respect the
doctor’s decision if she refused to evaluate her after learning who the particular acquaintance was. When she found out it concerned Mother Teresa, it
took Aubanel a couple of hours to contemplate a reply to the bishop’s plea. The doctor decided to go see the nun. After a brief examination, Aubanel
realized the severity of her condition, one that could only be resolved and attended to by a handful of people in the world and she was one of them.
Coincidence became Divine Providence.
Mother Teresa was immediately admitted to the Del Prado Medical Center, but her critical condition required her to go across the border to Scripps
Clinic for heart surgery, a trip that she refused to make. “I won’t be attended to in a hospital that cares for the rich and privileged,” she told
Aubanel. If the poor could not have this type of medical care, neither would she. Mother Teresa asked to be operated on at the medical center in
Tijuana, but the center did not have the means to undergo such treatment.
Aubanel attempted to convince Mother Teresa by explaining that her vows of poverty would not be affected; that, on the contrary, it was because of her
lifelong dedication to her work that she needed to be treated at any cost and in any place, in order to continue her mission. “There must be a reason
why I am here to help you,” Aubanel told Mother Teresa. “I am one of very few experts in the world that can treat your condition. I’ve never known how
to listen to God, but this time I feel a calling.” After a few days of trying to convince her, Mother Teresa still refused and told Aubanel that God
was her doctor and he would decide her fate.
Mother Teresa immediately stopped her medical treatment and the following day left Tijuana for Los Angeles to continue with her work. On the third day
in Los Angeles, Mother Teresa fell ill again and Aubanel got a call from Mother Teresa’s staff asking for advice. The doctor explained to them that in
her condition she needed to be admitted to a hospital as soon as possible. Mother Teresa once again refused, saying she preferred to be treated in
Tijuana. According to Aubanel, Mother Teresa had a special place in her heart for Tijuana; she felt closer to God there. Mother Teresa arrived in
Tijuana the next morning. The doctor was made to wait while Mother Teresa visited the Christmas festivities at her homes in Tijuana, and it wasn’t
until she returned at 10 p.m. that she allowed herself to be treated. She agreed to go to the hospital, but after Christmas.
On December 26, Mother Teresa was taken across the border to Scripps Clinic under the condition that she would not be accepted as Mother Teresa but by
her real name, Agnes Bojaxhiu. After a laboratory test, Aubanel found out that Mother Teresa had five obstructed arteries and decided on angioplasty;
one of the arteries required the placement of a stent. The operation was a success, yet, the stent procedure was still in clinical trials and required
FDA approval to be used on Mother Teresa. After her successful surgery, the stent became known by some in the medical community as the “holy” stent.
Building Faith
The effort made to save Mother Teresa’s life was a profound experience for Aubanel. After the operation, Mother Teresa entrusted the doctor with two
tasks: to create mobile health clinics to serve Tijuana’s underprivileged population; second, if Aubanel wished to bring back modern heart medicine to
Mexico, she had to build a cardiovascular center that would serve the whole community, rich and poor. The hospital would be built on the grounds of
the medical center Aubanel’s mother had built in Tijuana.
The doctor then went about raising funds for the center. She saved money, but the process was slow. Every time she flew around the world to see Mother
Teresa for her checkup she would have to tell her of the difficulty she was having raising money. After every visit, the nun would ask if she had
begun to build the center and the doctor would answer hesitantly, “I still don’t have enough funds.” Mother Teresa would reply, “You don’t need money;
all you need is faith.”
Mother Teresa passed away in 1997, and Aubanel would not wait any longer. She decided to begin construction with the funds she had at that moment. For
a last blessing, she asked permission to visit the nun’s grave in Calcutta. As she visited the site, she felt a deep spiritual approval to begin the
task. Before leaving, the doctor made one more request to the Council of the Missionaries of Charity at the convent. She wanted to name the center
after Mother Teresa. The nuns approved the request unanimously, and the Instituto de Ciencias Cardiovasculares Madre Teresa came to be.
Aubanel hired an unknown architect to design the building on what was part of the front plaza adjacent to the entrance of the medical center. Aubanel
began the work without consulting or intending to work with Morphosis — it was she who had been entrusted to begin the project by one of the most
devout spiritual leaders in the world; and due to Morphosis’ success in the architectural field, she thought they would be beyond her financial means.
By the late ’90s, the firm had matured and was becoming one of the most important practices in the Unites States and abroad, winning commissions and
awards for high-profile projects. Another concern Aubanel had was that, according to Mother Teresa, everything the doctor did under her name and
blessing had to be humble and unpretentious; Aubanel thought that by giving the project to a local architect, she would be true to this ideal. At the
end the new wing, a bland white stucco box with a pitched roof was attached to the original Morphosis building. “A crime to the building designed by
Livio, Michael, and Thom,” she explains, “but true to the needs of the new institute.”
Michael Rotondi thought the doctor’s preoccupation was reasonable, yet he felt that he would have considered working pro bono on the project. “If the
project is important enough, then we always find a way to make it happen.” The architect felt that Aubanel’s speculation regarding the firm’s success
was just a way to validate her predetermined decision. “Dr. Aubanel had other plans and commitments, I understand, but it’s too bad we never spoke. At
least it would have dispelled her preconceptions.”
Glass Chimera
If you go and visit the building today, you can walk up the marble stairs to the fourth floor and see its metal structure. The building’s green glass
block façade shimmers in the afternoon light and resembles Pierre Chareau’s glass house rather than the high modernism of James Stirling or Alvar
Aalto. The building did not make it into any architectural history book because just like any other late-modern structure, it could just be “part of
the platonic idea of building the ultimate glass box, one of many in the history of modernism,” as the British architectural historian Reyner Banham
said. The young architects who designed the building are now renowned architects. Michael Rotondi has his own practice with projects worldwide. Thom
Mayne still leads Morphosis and in 2005 received the Pritzker Architecture Prize for his lifetime achievement to the discipline of architecture.
Mother Teresa’s legacy was an important spiritual muse for the creation of the new wing of the cardiology medical center. Three young architects began
with a dream to have the liberty to experiment with avant-garde architectural ideas in a city that was just learning to be modern. And a doctor found
the faith and determination to provide world-class medical care in her home town. Tijuana once again becomes a place where faith and desire coalesce
creating multiple and improbable myths.
Special thanks to architect Miguel Escobar for facilitating the interview with Dr. Aubanel; architect Michael Rotondi for being kind enough to
elaborate on the commission and construction of the Riedel Medical Center. Finally, I want to thank Dr. Patricia Aubanel for her time and for sharing
the story of her relationship with Mother Teresa.