BajaNomad

OVERFISHING IN BAJA

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 10:40 AM

Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:

rpleger - 5-27-2009 at 10:44 AM

I agree that ALL fishing should be stoped for a period of five years to let the fish recover....a program similar to New Zealand would work for the Sea of Cortez.

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 10:49 AM

The people of New Zealand put the fish ahead of the charter businesses that catered to the flyfishing americans and decided to put the fish ahead of shortsighted lust for american dollars.

LaTijereta - 5-27-2009 at 10:57 AM

I see your point Mexprep..
Why would someone want to flyin to Loreto $500+ to stay and eat for 4 days in a hotel $300+, hire a pangaero for 2 days $400+ to catch a two dorado limit per day or four fish total:o

That is some very $$ filet....

BajaGeoff - 5-27-2009 at 10:57 AM

Who is really depleting the majority of the fish population though? I would think commercial fishing is having much more of an impact on the population than Americans flying in to fish. Do you have any statistics regarding this mexipep?

Well, lets do some rough math.

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 11:09 AM

Lets say you own a charter fish company on the Sea of Cortez.
Say you are open most of the year and have three boats available for charter. Lets say that five days a week you send two boats out with three guests and they catch one fish each as a low yield comparison. Thats over 1400 fish pulled per year out of one town based on a low estimate. Think about that number spread out all over the Sea of Cortez over any given year and you can see how it all adds up notwithstanding the other rock fish that are targeted when the migrating species are not caught on any given day.

So, three or four people in a charter company are responsible for all these fish when the locals could use that resource for food. That many fish could feed a lot of hungry people in this terrible economy but I am sure some here will try to justify it.

Osprey - 5-27-2009 at 11:13 AM

The government of Mexico has sold all the fish in the Sea of Cortez to long liners, factory ships, net boats without regard to the rights or needs of Mexicans who live along its shores. The wholesale harvesting of uncountable tons of all fish species over the last 7 or 8 decades makes all the sustainence fishing and sportfishing so small as to not be able to be measured against those trillions of tons of fish still being taken as we speak. The subject is moot.

Russ - 5-27-2009 at 11:13 AM

Problem solved! Commercial Fisheries have NEVER hurt any fish stocks any where. It's fishermen/women like me with our trout rods prowling the surf that have destroyed more fisheries than you can shack a rod at. DUH!

from BBC News yesterday:

Mulegena - 5-27-2009 at 11:16 AM

** 'Only 50 years left' for sea fish **
There will be virtually no fish or other seafood from the oceans by the middle of the century, scientists conclude.
< http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/em/fr/-/2/hi/science/nature/6108414... >

norte - 5-27-2009 at 11:28 AM

When I look past the obvious in Pepi's post, there is some merit to what he says. You want to save the gulf. then play no favorites... sorry Norte Americanos making a living or maybe just having fun.

Russ - 5-27-2009 at 11:29 AM

Pepe or what ever, You've been a member a whole day and you already sound like my worst nightmare.

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 11:34 AM

I would give up fishing and get tapedeck to help you fix that dirtbox golf course up as it might soon be the only fun you have left there in Punta Chivato. Maybe a nice windfarm could be a good project down there.;D

BMG - 5-27-2009 at 11:56 AM

Industrialized fish research.

What research do you have that sport fishing has anywhere near the impact on fisheries that commercial fishing has?

mulegemichael - 5-27-2009 at 12:08 PM

mexipep, it's apparent you have absolutely no clue regarding the commercial fishery that is occuring on the SOC....if you could see the miles and miles and miles of dead, drifting, floating bloated bycatch that the seiners and gillnetters leave behind maybe you MIGHT understand..but maybe not....the "catch and release" fishery that is now going full blast on baja has a negligible impact on fish populations....the dorado fishery would be, (and still IS), going strong in the SOC if it wasn't for the seiners who come in and take EVERYTHING that swims...how does that compare to my,(MAYBE), one or two dorado that i MIGHT catch when i go out?....draggers, longliners, gill netters, purse seiners...and me with my rod and reel...now..who's having the biggest negative impact?...no clue, amigo...

DanO - 5-27-2009 at 12:19 PM

Here's an interesting study that came out last fall about the positive economic effects of sport fishing at the cape, and the threat posed by commercial fishing.

http://www.sportfishingmag.com/news/news/-economic-impact-of...

Speaking for the Pacific side, I can tell you that the pangueros I know wouldn't be too keen to have American tourists banned from their boats. They're already in dire straits because of the drop off in tourism due to the lagging economy and the overblown narco violence and influenza scares. But hey, let them eat uni, eh pep?

BMG - 5-27-2009 at 12:25 PM

Sea Watch

gnukid - 5-27-2009 at 12:32 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:


Racist

Festus - 5-27-2009 at 12:45 PM

Pepe:

Your math appears to be flawed. You don't take into account that many sports fisherman practice catch and release. I release everything I catch down there unless the panguero wants to keep one or two to feed his family that night. Would you take food from their mouths?

The number of sports fish caught is immaterial versus the number of fish gill netted by locals or commercial fisherman. Your solution would simply deprive the Baja economy of a substantial income source while providing a negligible impact on the quantity of fish taken out of Baja waters.

toneart - 5-27-2009 at 12:49 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mulegemichael
mexipep, it's apparent you have absolutely no clue regarding the commercial fishery that is occuring on the SOC....if you could see the miles and miles and miles of dead, drifting, floating bloated bycatch that the seiners and gillnetters leave behind maybe you MIGHT understand..but maybe not....the "catch and release" fishery that is now going full blast on baja has a negligible impact on fish populations....the dorado fishery would be, (and still IS), going strong in the SOC if it wasn't for the seiners who come in and take EVERYTHING that swims...how does that compare to my,(MAYBE), one or two dorado that i MIGHT catch when i go out?....draggers, longliners, gill netters, purse seiners...and me with my rod and reel...now..who's having the biggest negative impact?...no clue, amigo...


Thank you Michael, soulpatch and Osprey!

You place the blame where it belongs. It is heartbreaking to witness this ecological disaster. We non-nationals are powerless to intervene or even protest. I have signed petitions, but they did no good.

We have to hold current fishing licenses and follow the letter of the law when fishing (single lining). We cannot take shell fish. We are bound by species limits, and we are boarded and checked often, while the culprits you accurately mention are allowed to violate the law. Furthermore, I believe that for most of us (certainly not all), that our culture has it that we are self monitoring.

However, if there were an international ban of fishing for a period of years, so as to allow the fish to regenerate, I would be for it.

What international body would have jurisdiction? How would they monitor Mexico or Japan or other blatant violators? How can you hold nations accountable who look the other way when their own citizens violate the law? What would be the consequences?

It is too bad that environmental causes have been so politicized. That rhetoric has caused some to consider conservation not necessary, or worse yet, the need is denied.

To NOT practice conservation is not only illegal in most regions, it is also immoral. Most of us who have boats, love the sea and fish, know this.:light:

Cypress - 5-27-2009 at 01:05 PM

Festus, You hit the nail right on the head!:bounce: Subsistance and commercial fishing will result in starvation or malnutrition for those depending upon that for their daily bread. It will only lead to a further depletion of the Sea of Cortez's dwindling fish stocks. The're scraping the bottom of the barrel. Seems to be a lot of stingrays left. Yummy.

CaboRon - 5-27-2009 at 01:08 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:


Interesting comments considering it is the mexicans who are doing a good share of the overfishing and the taking of endangered species .....

And it is the mexicans who have sold their heritage to the commerical fisheries combined with basically no enforcement of the laws in effect ....

Mexiass you are clueless .... I for one would be happy never to spend another dime supporting your rip off sport fishery.




[Edited on 5-27-2009 by CaboRon]

toneart - 5-27-2009 at 01:19 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by CaboRon
Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:


Interesting comments considering it is the mexicans who are doing a good share of the overfishing and the taking of endangered species .....


Interesting comments considering this newby condones eating turtle on the turtle thread. The only consistency I see in his posts is the hostility against Nomads and North Americans.

Therefore, his call for conservation holds no credibility. :yawn:
Other new Hydra Troll(s) also bear watching....same agenda.:yes:

capt. mike - 5-27-2009 at 01:32 PM

mexipep....thx for piping up.
i was wondering when this board would find a new idiot.

and...keep drinking that single malt.
soon you'll be down to a single brain cell from 2.
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

signed...a "flyin" Yankee.

Cypress - 5-27-2009 at 01:37 PM

mexipep, Hang in there!

Did you read my original post?

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 02:44 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by toneart
Quote:
Originally posted by CaboRon
Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:


Interesting comments considering it is the mexicans who are doing a good share of the overfishing and the taking of endangered species .....


Interesting comments considering this newby condones eating turtle on the turtle thread. The only consistency I see in his posts is the hostility against Nomads and North Americans.

Therefore, his call for conservation holds no credibility. :yawn:
Other new Hydra Troll(s) also bear watching....same agenda.:yes:


I never said the seiners and the like should continue their rape of the seas. I said the small commercial panga owners and citizens should fish for subsistance. As for the turtle input,its was said in jest based on the foolish posts on the thread that preceded it. Why is it you americans must look for a culprit when you are part of the problem.:fire:

Ahh, heres a bright light/

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 02:58 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by capt. mike
mexipep....thx for piping up.
i was wondering when this board would find a new idiot.

and...keep drinking that single malt.
soon you'll be down to a single brain cell from 2.
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

signed...a "flyin" Yankee.


A flying yankee who insults from the hip.
Well my turn. I have just read your last 50 posts and one thing is for certain. You are the biggest tire kicker on the planet. Whenever a place comes up for sale,you pretend to be interested in it and then back off cause 'its not the right time' because you did not win the irish sweepstakes or some other tripe. Your great claim to fame is you rented a pad at an old hotel for your old motorhome and you are an expert on all things Baja. You only come down when you can 'split the av gas' or in other words you are much too cheap or as we say a skinflint or a little dodgey.

Save it for the next poor fools you hoodwink into paying you with gas to fly them as they will be so nervous ,they will agree with everything you say.:lol:

Thank you

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 03:00 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Cypress
mexipep, Hang in there!


There are some gentlemen on this board.

Your one or two fish?

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 03:06 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mulegemichael
mexipep, it's apparent you have absolutely no clue regarding the commercial fishery that is occuring on the SOC....if you could see the miles and miles and miles of dead, drifting, floating bloated bycatch that the seiners and gillnetters leave behind maybe you MIGHT understand..but maybe not....the "catch and release" fishery that is now going full blast on baja has a negligible impact on fish populations....the dorado fishery would be, (and still IS), going strong in the SOC if it wasn't for the seiners who come in and take EVERYTHING that swims...how does that compare to my,(MAYBE), one or two dorado that i MIGHT catch when i go out?....draggers, longliners, gill netters, purse seiners...and me with my rod and reel...now..who's having the biggest negative impact?...no clue, amigo...



So if everyone just takes one or two thats ok,
What a daft attitude. Are you all there man. What are you thinking? If every rotund yank such as yourself takes two everytime you go out,what do you think the daily total would be for that body of water as a whole or is this question rather taxing for you.

What a collection of fools who jump on their keyboards without thinking but that is not a surprize here.
Think before you post and at least try to use the brain the good lord gave you.

tripledigitken - 5-27-2009 at 03:07 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Quote:
Originally posted by capt. mike
mexipep....thx for piping up.
i was wondering when this board would find a new idiot.

and...keep drinking that single malt.
soon you'll be down to a single brain cell from 2.
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

signed...a "flyin" Yankee.


A flying yankee who insults from the hip.
Well my turn. I have just read your last 50 posts and one thing is for certain. You are the biggest tire kicker on the planet. Whenever a place comes up for sale,you pretend to be interested in it and then back off cause 'its not the right time' because you did not win the irish sweepstakes or some other tripe. Your great claim to fame is you rented a pad at an old hotel for your old motorhome and you are an expert on all things Baja. You only come down when you can 'split the av gas' or in other words you are much too cheap or as we say a skinflint or a little dodgey.

Save it for the next poor fools you hoodwink into paying you with gas to fly them as they will be so nervous ,they will agree with everything you say.:lol:


Mexipep,

You certainly sound familar with your personal insults. Why did it take you so long to come back in with a new name?

Like Fulano and Palmetto (I suspect your alter egos) you get nastier as the day goes on. Maybe it's time for a nap?

Ken

BMG - 5-27-2009 at 03:56 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep

I said the small commercial panga owners and citizens should fish for subsistance.

No, that is not what you said.

You said:
Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep

I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.

There are big differences in the two statements.

cantinflas - 5-27-2009 at 04:19 PM

Mexipep you are obviously a clueless little tallywacker who knows nothing about fish stocks,fishing and the Sea of Cortez.

DENNIS - 5-27-2009 at 04:22 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep

There are some gentlemen on this board.



What....Where? There's not supposed to be. We have rules, ya know.

Cypress - 5-27-2009 at 05:41 PM

DENNIS,:biggrin: mexipep is a good judge of character.:yes:

mulegemichael - 5-27-2009 at 05:53 PM

oh man....oh man...isn't there a trapdoor someplace we could send this clueless a**hole down?...it seems so unfair that people like this can actually task us with their incredibly droll, uninformed, uneducated drivel...go away...please...i beg you..

losfrailes - 5-27-2009 at 05:56 PM

Quit responding to his nonsense, he will have no where to go.

Responding justifies his posting.

DENNIS - 5-27-2009 at 06:04 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Cypress
DENNIS,:biggrin: mexipep is a good judge of character.:yes:



In your case, I have to agree. :spingrin:

805gregg - 5-27-2009 at 07:42 PM

Personally I think they should close the golf courses to all non mexicans.

DENNIS - 5-27-2009 at 07:48 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by 805gregg
Personally I think they should close the golf courses to all non mexicans.


And all those wasteful winerys. If things continue as they are, they're won't be a grape left in the whole country.

Alan - 5-27-2009 at 08:12 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by mexipep
Conservation must start somewhere and something must be done about the over fishing in the Sea of Cortez. I say that fishing be closed to all non Mexicans and be open only for commercial and subsistance fishing only for the benefit of Mexican citizens.
Some here will insist that there is an economic benefit with the charter fishery but someone show me where sports overfishing
helps the local economies. The fish belong to the Mexican people and are not the property of rich flyin americans.:fire:

I am quite surprised that any one of you thought you might have found a sufficiently intelligent remark anywhere in this post that would be worthy of a response.

Never argue with an idiot in public. Spectators may not be able to tell the difference.

Ignore him

The yanks are swarming.an attack is coming

mexipep - 5-27-2009 at 08:34 PM

Do you notice all the obnoxious yanks who insist on telling everyone who will listen what idiots we are if we blame them for anything. The days of your forcing your ways on to the rest of the world are over yanks. You are broke, have no morals and are bankrupt in every sense of the word. Even the Mexicans are laughing at you as are the people in Europe. You are in demise so accept it and practice chinese if you know whats good for you.Ha ha hahahhahahahahahahahaaha:lol::lol::lol::lol:

mulegemichael - 5-27-2009 at 08:50 PM

oh boy!...i'm just now on my way down to my casa in mulege...oh boy...where did we come up with this guy from???...i am just aghast!..really...i really am...and..i don't think i have any responses to him that i would deem appropriate on this site...maybe in private...but it's too bad...i KNOW he referred to me as a "bit large" in his last email so he must have inside info...so...i think he's just a friggin buddy that knows it all and it's all a joke..i dunno!...is this a dream?..we will be home tomorrow night and i'll give it a day or two to sink in but ...this guy is really TRYING to stir the pot....i'm not buying into it...whatta bout you?

805gregg - 5-27-2009 at 09:22 PM

Maybe not rent hotel rooms to anyone but a Mexican National, that would fix everything, how about no plane flights unless you are a citizen. That should cut out on crowding. Mexipimp you should flame somewhere else. Most people here love Mexico and Mexicans, and would do nothing to hurt the place and the people they love.

Cypress - 5-28-2009 at 05:24 AM

Depending on the bounty of the Sea of Cortez for survival? That'd take care of any obesity issues down in Baja.:biggrin:

capt. mike - 5-28-2009 at 05:59 AM

hahahaha!!!!!!!!! you read MY last 50 posts??!!

you must be awfully damn bored. :lol::lol::lol::lol:

DENNIS - 5-28-2009 at 06:02 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by capt. mike
hahahaha!!!!!!!!! you read MY last 50 posts??!!

you must be awfully damn bored. :lol::lol::lol::lol:


You're talking to the dead, Mike. He/she's history.

DanO - 5-28-2009 at 09:24 AM

Awwwww.

:no:

DENNIS - 5-28-2009 at 09:31 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by DanO
Awwwww.

:no:



And, you guys were getting along so well. :lol:

DanO - 5-28-2009 at 09:42 AM

It's OK. I'm over it now.

Sharksbaja - 5-28-2009 at 02:19 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by tripledigitken


Like Fulano and Palmetto (I suspect your alter egos) you get nastier as the day goes on. Maybe it's time for a nap?

Ken


It was Palmetto or should we use his real name(Pierce). His written English errors bust him every time.:rolleyes:

------

Personally, I'd like to see some areas have moratoriums on all fishing for a few years. It's proven that fisheries improve drammatically doing this.