BajaNomad

What temporary shelters are good for baja?

standingwave - 9-7-2013 at 07:42 PM

I am looking for a large tent/enclosure for my next Baja trip. Something along the lines of a swap meet tent or a pole and fabric car shelter. Dimensions around 12' by 16'. I am interested in peoples' experiences with these temporary shelters in Baja. Which ones stand up to the winds? to the sun? What have you used that works well?

Curt63 - 9-7-2013 at 07:57 PM

Caravan makes an excellent 10x10 portable shelter with walls. Should be about $200 at Costco online. Quality construction and lasts a long time.

DENNIS - 9-7-2013 at 08:13 PM

Marriot. :light:

standingwave - 9-8-2013 at 05:57 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by Curt63
Caravan makes an excellent 10x10 portable shelter with walls. Should be about $200 at Costco online. Quality construction and lasts a long time.


too small :-(

woody with a view - 9-8-2013 at 06:06 AM

u2u Don Jorge. he has the most bad azz shelter i've ever seen.

standingwave - 9-8-2013 at 06:16 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by DENNIS
Marriot. :light:


too big :-(

standingwave - 9-8-2013 at 06:21 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by woody with a view
u2u Don Jorge. he has the most bad azz shelter i've ever seen.


thnx, Woody. U2U on its way

mojo_norte - 9-8-2013 at 06:41 AM

Costco carries (or did) a larger 'portable' garage' - pole and white tarpaulin - and I've seen people use them for a season in moderate windy conditions with some additional tie downs .

wilderone - 9-8-2013 at 07:57 AM

While I don't have a specific recommendation for a product, I would make a suggestion based on my motto: "Go Light, Go Now." Bigger is heavier, is a larger silhouette for wind forces, takes longer to put up. If you're thinking of staying put in one place in this thing (once up, once down) for an extended period, I suppose would be worth complicated construction time. In Baja you need AIR FLOW. Without actual experience with one, I might consider a screen tent. You can see the view you came for, have protection from bugs, air flow, rain roof, cook safely inside it. As far as wind, yes, the wind can blow and brings the sand with it. Extra tie downs - tied to your car, a boulder, a tree - are necessary. Inside, weatherproof all your belongings. You could always have multiple shelters like Graham McIntosh does - he has a sleeping tent, a cooking tent, an equipment tent. Improvising based on the exact locale is done as the days go by. Find a site with natural protections and advantages. E.g., don't set up on the edge of the top of a cliff where the winds will howl and kick up dirt. Some natural shade would be good as well. You could also have a smaller sleeping tent inside to protect from sand blows.

Bob and Susan - 9-8-2013 at 08:27 AM

this one is ALWAYS my favorite

123.jpg - 26kB

MMc - 9-8-2013 at 09:35 AM

I haven't seen Don Jorge's set up but I do like mine.
It is 14.5 X 14.5, the size was determined by the truck bed I had the time. It is bullet proof. Takes about 20 min or so to set up.
The frame is a 3/4" swap-meet awning using 3/4 emt cut to size.
There are 6 down poles and the middle is raised about 15' higher. The tarp is a custom made out of Shelter-Rite truck tarp, reenforced on all edges with 2.5" webbing and grommets for bungees. It runs across the top and down the back,it can be nailed down across the back.The sides are custom made out of the same material, a little short can't be nailed. This trap has out lasted and taken more of a beating then others. The sides are used when it get nasty most times they are down or only 1 is used on the windward side
The whole thing fits in a black and yellow plastic box. The polls are the same length and duct taped together in 6 poll units for transport. The stakes are re-bar or giant nails.
The front gets 5gal. buckets filled with water, sand or rocks on all the down poles. The black box is filled with the same material and tied off in the middle in the back. When it get really windy I part the truck in front to help break the wind. All the tie-downs are 1' climb spec. or 6mm spectra. Most think it's over built until it gets bad.This set up has been in 50+ mile winds and pouring rains. On one trip a pole was warped and replaced.

There are lots of places on line at sell the frames and tarps. The silver heavy tarps are cooler then the blue or white. At one time there was a place at the OC swap meet but they are out of business.

[Edited on 9-8-2013 by MMc]

mtgoat666 - 9-8-2013 at 11:04 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by standingwave
I am looking for a large tent/enclosure for my next Baja trip. Something along the lines of a swap meet tent or a pole and fabric car shelter. Dimensions around 12' by 16'. I am interested in peoples' experiences with these temporary shelters in Baja. Which ones stand up to the winds? to the sun? What have you used that works well?


you want cheap and wind-proof? try a military surplus tent. here is a 17x17 you can pick up for $450 in los angeles:



these tents weigh a bit, but have walls that can be opened up when the wind dies (if the wind dies :lol::lol::lol: )

mtgoat666 - 9-8-2013 at 11:06 AM

you can get this 18x18 for $800


willardguy - 9-8-2013 at 11:27 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by mtgoat666
Quote:
Originally posted by standingwave
I am looking for a large tent/enclosure for my next Baja trip. Something along the lines of a swap meet tent or a pole and fabric car shelter. Dimensions around 12' by 16'. I am interested in peoples' experiences with these temporary shelters in Baja. Which ones stand up to the winds? to the sun? What have you used that works well?


you want cheap and wind-proof? try a military surplus tent. here is a 17x17 you can pick up for $450 in los angeles:



these tents weigh a bit, but have walls that can be opened up when the wind dies (if the wind dies :lol::lol::lol: )
looks familiar!


Curt63 - 9-8-2013 at 12:06 PM

These work well for beach camping. I asked about the flat roof and my friend said its best for the wind. a pitched roof gets blown worse. He said sometimes you have to use a broom stick to remove a heavy overnight dew. This is from Ace Canopy online. I know nothing about this vendor.

Canopy

Alm - 9-8-2013 at 12:24 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by standingwave
Which ones stand up to the winds? to the sun?

Any shelter in Baja you have to stake or tie down to really heavy rocks. And if you do, then it will make no difference what brand or design - whatever is cheaper. Fabric will deteriorate with time, but you said that it has to be a "temporary" shelter. Poles on cheaper shelters are usually steel and the surface will corrode after a while, but it will still work.

MMc - 9-8-2013 at 12:32 PM

I really disagree about going cheap the EMT has held up very well. We wash everything when we get home. My Vinyl is still water proof. It was not inexpensive but it was out lasted all my friends tarps and is used as much or more then there's. I believe in getting the right product for the job and maintaining well.

I like a slight pitch, works better in the rain. If we're leaving camp when we have big wind we lift the backside on top.
This is about what we have with all poles being same. Much easier to pack same length polls.

http://creativeshelters1.reachlocal.net/Design-Tools/Cut-Lis...

Air flow is not a issue.

[Edited on 9-8-2013 by MMc]

[Edited on 9-8-2013 by MMc]

Netting

bajaguy - 9-8-2013 at 12:53 PM

This stuff works great

https://www.camonettingstore.com/surplus-camo-netting/

freediverbrian - 9-8-2013 at 03:17 PM

Had a pitched cover with the silver tarp on it, the corner legs in five gallon concret buckets . A gust of wind in gonzaga picked up the cover and turned it upside down. The netting is a good idea less wind resistence.

durrelllrobert - 9-8-2013 at 05:13 PM

I once designed and built a shelter for an outside kitchen/dining area for a restaurant. it was 12' x 16', open on one side, and because it set on the beach in the Federal zone it had to be easy to disassemble and take down. It consisted of eleven 4x'8' panels, each reinforced with 2x3 x 8' at 24" on center + top and bottom (4 pieces per panel total). The center 2x3 on each panel was attached to a steel studded fence post (see picture) that was first driven into the ground about 12" (depending on how deep the sand was) on 4' centers.



For a 12' x 16' enclosure that is open on one end a total of 11 panels are required for the walls and 6 more are required for the flat roof for a total of 17. When these a stacked in your truck bed for transportation the stack will be 4'x8' x 26" high.

The material needed for all 17 panes is as follows:
(17) 4'x8' x 3/8" plywood
(68) 2x3 x 8'
(11) steel studded fence post
About 1 pound 1" long drywall screws

Total cost should be less than $500

edit: forgot picture

[Edited on 9-9-2013 by durrelllrobert]

MMc - 9-8-2013 at 05:22 PM

Was there concrete in the buckets? Had a buddy do the same on the pacific side his was not staked down.

Tips for wind:
Set up with the wind in mind. sometimes we put a corner in the wind and let the bungee flex in the wind.

Put your truck/car as a windbreak.

The poles need to be able to stay on top of the soil, we use rocks or paper plates anything flat.

Also we will bury the buckets in sand or dirt like a dead-man. The week link is the handle so it was replaced with spectra.

Having a 100 Qt container filled with water tied to the center back really helps. The container is the storage vestal for the tarp parts.

Not having the bungees super tight helps.

Not screwing the downside pole tight also helps, It will allow the pole and fitting to move a bit. The tie-down keep the poles from lifting all the way off.

Do not pulling the tie downs completely tight helps, like lofting a sail.

I have never done it but you could just pull the down-poles out and give a lower profile

We use are tarp year round and need cover from the rain.

woody with a view - 9-8-2013 at 05:44 PM

i'll go out on a limb and say Don Jorge has one of these, or something very similar: http://www.cabelas.com/browse.cmd?categoryId=153410580

Alm - 9-8-2013 at 05:54 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by MMc
My Vinyl is still water proof. It was not inexpensive but it was out lasted all my friends tarps and is used as much or more then there's. I believe in getting the right product for the job and maintaining well.

I like a slight pitch, works better in the rain. If we're leaving camp when we have big wind we lift the backside on top.
This is about what we have with all poles being same. Much easier to pack same length polls.

http://creativeshelters1.reachlocal.net/Design-Tools/Cut-Lis...

I like their approach, and prices too. Only couldn't make DIY tool work. Enter the values, click on "display my design", and nothing happens. I like those heavy duty silver and green tarps that they have. What vinyl tarp do you have? The are mostly polyethylene.

MMc - 9-8-2013 at 06:36 PM

The tarp is a custom made with this stuff.
http://www.shelterritetarps.com/
It's 14oz in a wine color. The seams are heat melted together and is super strong. I didn't go with a standard size because I wanted it to be as big as I could and have it fit in the back of the truck. The truck bed was 87.5" long so 87" was the size. I wanted all poles the same length, so the tarp had to be custom made. Form following function. Really happy with the whole thing 20+ years later.
The silver is cooler to be under.
If you ever see it up stop by. We'll have a cold one:)

[Edited on 9-9-2013 by MMc]

tripledigitken - 9-8-2013 at 06:41 PM

MMC,

Where do we look for it?

Ken

woody with a view - 9-8-2013 at 06:42 PM

......by the cactus, near the point.

tripledigitken - 9-8-2013 at 06:45 PM

Don't suppose you have coordinates?

MMc - 9-8-2013 at 07:00 PM

You'll know when you see it! There will be surf and good times for all.
"Coordinates" you guys are killing me, let me get out my map :no:

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Taco de Baja - 9-9-2013 at 08:22 AM

I have been using a 10x10 low-pitch roof swap meet structure for years; it can also be converted to a 10x20 for larger groups as in the attached picture with 3 additional fittings.

We wrap the sides with shade cloth to help cut out some, but not all of the wind, otherwise it would get too hot, plus cut down on the sun coming in the sides. Because of the bungees that hold on the top there is less chance for it to take off in a strong wind; plus it vents heat better than an "Easy-Up". I just this year had to order some new bungees as a few of the 8 year old ones were losing their stretch.

Definitely go with a top that is silver on top and white below. In this 2009 photo the one on the left was white on top and bottom, and a thinner mil, and there was a considerable heat difference between the two with the left side being hotter. Both are currently silver topped, and the same heavy mil thickness.

This is not really suitable for rain protection as we found out on Aug 25 of this year at midnight when the leading edge of Ivo hit us. Rain blows in the front, drips in the middles and edges....not fun with 5 people trying to sleep and worrying about packing up for home in the rain in a few hours....:lol:

BTW it takes around 2 hours start to finish to set up with 3 people, and the same to take down. So this is more for camping in an area where you will be for several days.

I believe mine uses the 1 3/8" pipe. Most kits do not come with the poles, you have to go to Home Depot for those.
For the 10x10 you'll need 9 10-foot sections, of which you'll be cutting off ~4' for the leg poles, depending on how tall you want it.
For the 10x20 you'll need 15 10-foot sections, of which you'll be cutting off ~4' for 6 leg poles.
Although not cheap, and heavy, go with steel, not PVC

Also, if you want a 10x16, you can simply use 8-foot poles for the roof beam and sides rather than the 10 footers. They also make joiners to hook up two sections, if you don’t have the room to haul 10 or 8 foot lengths of pipe.

I got my kit off eBay, but don't recall the seller. I got the "Heavy-duty" kit that included the fittings, bungees, and the tarp. The "medium-duty" had smaller diameter eye-bolts to attach the poles to the fittings, a less mil-thickness on the tarp, and steel eyelet on the trap rather than brass. The "light-duty" one down-grades to 1 inch or maybe 3/4 inch pipe (definitely not suitable for Baja :lol: ). I also got the foot pads that you can pile rocks on or use long spikes to nail into the ground for added wind safety.



[Edited on 9-9-2013 by Taco de Baja]

DavidE - 9-9-2013 at 10:39 AM

Buckets? At Punta Chivato the wind pulled the bails right out of their sockets on buckets filled with sand and seawater. The best anchors seem to be tires with click ratchet tensioners and ultra-heavy duty bungees for shock absorbsion. I used a ripstop nylon parachute for years and years.

woody with a view - 9-9-2013 at 12:10 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Taco de Baja


[Edited on 9-9-2013 by Taco de Baja]


were there still trailers at the next bump to the north? just as you cross the salt flat heading north? last time in they looked pretty dug in and we marveled at the nerves of steel to get them into that spot.... oh, and the Osprey nest right above you guys is pretty cool!

[Edited on 9-9-2013 by woody with a view]

Taco de Baja - 9-9-2013 at 01:10 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by woody with a view

were there still trailers at the next bump to the north? just as you cross the salt flat heading north? last time in they looked pretty dug in and we marveled at the nerves of steel to get them into that spot.... oh, and the Osprey nest right above you guys is pretty cool!

[Edited on 9-9-2013 by woody with a view]


No trailers or tents at that point this year. Completely deserted. That place seems to have different people in different conditions every time we pass by. Several years ago as we were heading home a guy came running out of his tent to flag us down. He wanted to sell us almejas. He was initially bummed when we declined. But perked up when we gave him a bunch of leftover food we could not bring back and did not really need: fruits, veggies, chips, crackers, salami, and a half bottle of Cuervo. Man he was happy to see that!

Only people we really saw this trip were some guys from Punta Blanca who stopped by on our first night to see if we had some sodas and cervezas they could have for their road trip into town [saw them again on our way out when we stopped at the La Virgen shrine near the paved road to pay our respects, get some of the mud off, and discover I had a leaky tire. If we had not stopped, I may not have noticed and possibly blown it out on the highway Thanks La Virgen! :saint: . They offered to help, in the Baja tradition, but I about had it plugged and declined.], and another couple of guys who drove all the way from Blanca the day it rained to see if we had some lighters (on our last day). We of course gave them several lighters and most of our leftover sodas and beer.

There are some fishermen living on the point to the south, but we had no contact with them.

There were two Osprey nests this year.

Ill try to work up a photo trip report sometime soon....with key landmarks redacted, of course :lol:

woody with a view - 9-9-2013 at 04:43 PM

that house up on the point is a trip. cant imagine who built it way up there, but anyway.

redacted, of course!

Mexitron - 9-9-2013 at 05:05 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by Taco de Baja
I have been using a 10x10 low-pitch roof swap meet structure for years; it can also be converted to a 10x20 for larger groups as in the attached picture with 3 additional fittings.

We wrap the sides with shade cloth to help cut out some, but not all of the wind, otherwise it would get too hot, plus cut down on the sun coming in the sides. Because of the bungees that hold on the top there is less chance for it to take off in a strong wind; plus it vents heat better than an "Easy-Up". I just this year had to order some new bungees as a few of the 8 year old ones were losing their stretch.

Definitely go with a top that is silver on top and white below. In this 2009 photo the one on the left was white on top and bottom, and a thinner mil, and there was a considerable heat difference between the two with the left side being hotter. Both are currently silver topped, and the same heavy mil thickness.

This is not really suitable for rain protection as we found out on Aug 25 of this year at midnight when the leading edge of Ivo hit us. Rain blows in the front, drips in the middles and edges....not fun with 5 people trying to sleep and worrying about packing up for home in the rain in a few hours....:lol:

BTW it takes around 2 hours start to finish to set up with 3 people, and the same to take down. So this is more for camping in an area where you will be for several days.

I believe mine uses the 1 3/8" pipe. Most kits do not come with the poles, you have to go to Home Depot for those.
For the 10x10 you'll need 9 10-foot sections, of which you'll be cutting off ~4' for the leg poles, depending on how tall you want it.
For the 10x20 you'll need 15 10-foot sections, of which you'll be cutting off ~4' for 6 leg poles.
Although not cheap, and heavy, go with steel, not PVC

Also, if you want a 10x16, you can simply use 8-foot poles for the roof beam and sides rather than the 10 footers. They also make joiners to hook up two sections, if you don’t have the room to haul 10 or 8 foot lengths of pipe.

I got my kit off eBay, but don't recall the seller. I got the "Heavy-duty" kit that included the fittings, bungees, and the tarp. The "medium-duty" had smaller diameter eye-bolts to attach the poles to the fittings, a less mil-thickness on the tarp, and steel eyelet on the trap rather than brass. The "light-duty" one down-grades to 1 inch or maybe 3/4 inch pipe (definitely not suitable for Baja :lol: ). I also got the foot pads that you can pile rocks on or use long spikes to nail into the ground for added wind safety.



[Edited on 9-9-2013 by Taco de Baja]


Huddo! Wonder if we'll ever see him there again...

standingwave - 9-11-2013 at 06:19 AM

hmm.... a nice variety of possibilities. Thank you all.

Taco de Baja. Is your structure strong enough to hold a hammock strung diagonally across?

Don Jorge: Thanks for the link. http://forums.bajanomad.com/viewthread.php?tid=58057&pag... A very nice setup!

MMc: Did you get your custom tarp from ShelterRite in Ohio? Or from a westcoast source?

MMc - 9-11-2013 at 06:52 AM

I was made locally but the company is out of business. Most of the places that work vinyl can do it, think awning, truck tarps, boat covers. You want it heat fused at the seams. the rest is sewing and such.

Taco de Baja - 9-11-2013 at 07:47 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by standingwave
hmm.... a nice variety of possibilities. Thank you all.

Taco de Baja. Is your structure strong enough to hold a hammock strung diagonally across?


I wouldn't string a hammock. It's not really that strong, or designed for that. Maybe with the super-heavy duty kits that use 1-5/8" or 1-7/8" chain link fence posts instead of 1-3/8" tubing...but that's adding a lot of weight. Some kits also add a horizontal beam below the roof peak (the 10 foot wide sections in the photo) which should help add some structural support in the corners....All we hang from the structure are beach towels, wet-suits, bathing suits, lanterns, bags of fruit, potatoes, and the like. So we did not need the extra support.

The kids, being kids, will occasionally swing around on the vertical poles like monkeys, but an immediate "STOP THAT IT'S NOT SAFE!" puts a stop to it. So far no damage from the monkeys :lol: .

If you want a hammock, I'd recommend using stand alone poles with guy wires (Which, of course, can be dangerous especially at night after a few beers :light: )