BajaNomad
Not logged in [Login - Register]

Go To Bottom
Printable Version  
 Pages:  1  
Author: Subject: Residente Permanente and Driving a US registered/plated vehicle
MitchMan
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1855
Registered: 3-9-2009
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 10:48 AM
Residente Permanente and Driving a US registered/plated vehicle


Picked up my Residente Permanente card in La Paz yesterday and talked to the people there about a Residente Permannte holder's permissibility to drive an owned US registered/plated vehicle in La Paz. None of INM people knew about any controversy and they responded emphatically that it was absolutely positively OK for a Residente Permanente to drive his US registered/plated vehicle in La Paz with impunity.

There happened to be two attorneys in the office that were there in their capacity to assist clients in obtaining visas. The older attorney was emphatic that it was OK for an RP to drive his US vehicle in LA Paz. The younger attorney was equally emphatic that it was OK. He further stated, emphatically, that because the Baja was all Free Zone territory, that any laws that prohibit an RP from driving his US owned and registered/plated vehicle in Mexico absolutely and positively did not apply to any part of the Baja because it is all Free Zone territory.

Then I showed the two attorneys a copy of a letter on SHCP-SAT-Aduana letterhead that was a response to an RP request of is options on renewing/obtaining a TIP on his US registered/plated Dodge so that he could drive it in Mexico. The letter, in no uncertain terms, told him that he could not get a TIP with the implication being that he is not allowed to drive such a vehicle in Mexico.

The logic of the letter emphasizes that TIPs are related to that "regime" of Mexican law that relates to temporary residents in Mexico and the corresponding temporary permissions given to such temporary residents. Temporary permissions are not provided for in that "regimen" of Mexican law that relates to "PERMANENT" residents.

The implication is that TIPs are limited to Temporary visitors and not to permanent residents and whether or not you, as an RP, are in a Free Zone/Prohibited territory is irrelevant. The only relevancy regarding the Free Zone is for temporary residents. If you are a temporary resident in the interior of the mainland Mexico, then you can get a TIP. If you are a temporary resident in the Baja Free Zone, you don't need a permit.

After reading the letter, the personnel at the INM in La Paz and the two attorneys kind of became mute and I could see the "pause" in their demeanor. I am corresponding with the younger attorney and he said that his going to look into the matter and contact the relevant authorities to get further input. The older attorney had attitude, was rather intolerant/impatient, short talking, didactic and feigned an air of authority...all characteristics of someone who tries to bully his position instead of researching and instead of remaining open to new information.

[Edited on 7-13-2013 by MitchMan]
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
monoloco
Elite Nomad
******




Posts: 6667
Registered: 7-13-2009
Location: Pescadero BCS
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 11:36 AM


I am not going to worry about it until I hear of people being harassed about it. If the lawyers and INM can't figure out the rules, how would anyone expect the average gringo to? It just seems like a solution looking for a problem at this point, other than at INM and airports, I have never had anyone ask us for immigration docs in over 30 years of Baja travel and living.



"The future ain't what it used to be"
View user's profile
norte
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1163
Registered: 10-8-2008
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 11:57 AM


May I ask Mr Mitch why you are pressing this even after they said no problem?.....to the uninformed seems as though you want your letter recognized to be the law. Not something I would think most expaats would desire.

edited for spelling

[Edited on 7-13-2013 by norte]
View user's profile
MitchMan
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1855
Registered: 3-9-2009
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 01:44 PM


My issue is to definitively ascertain what is actually legal and what is not. The best info I have is what I posted. I have a stake in this. As I wrote, I just got my Residente Permanente yesterday. I have a Tacoma that has US Plates and I have two boat that have US plates on the trailers and one of the boats s longer than 4.5 meters and required a TIP to be used by me on the water here in Baja.

NOw with the RP status, I am trying to discern the law and whether or not I can legally drive my truck and pull my boats here in Baja. MY interpretation of things so far is that it is illegal for me to drive my truck and to pull and to use my boats here in Baja.

Obviously, I want to be able to drive my truck and pull my boats in Baja, but I absolutely need to know my actual legal ability to do so. If I can't, I have two general options: 1)change my status to Residente Temporal and continue to use my vehicle and my boats here without any more hassle and money, or 2) incur the time and energy and thousands of dollars to nationalize my truck and boats. But, in order to do anything, I need to know the actual law.

That's how I view it. If others take the position that there is no problem if they don't hear of any confiscations and are quite happy and contented to not know the actual law in this matter, fine. I do not argue with your choices. But for me, a starting point is to know the actual applicable law, and secondarily to know what is ultimately and reliably going to be the application of the law in Baja.

So, norte, I am not advocating a position other than to intelligently ascertain the on point legality of what is transpiring. If you think \that I am advocating something, that is your inference. I am hoping that I can keep my RP status and drive my US plated truck and pull and use my US registered boats while in Baja, but, so far, based on the best info that I have come across, it doesn't look like it. This is not being adversarial, this is being objective.

If anyone has hard evidence or current documented evidence to the contrary, please submit.
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
Mula
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1654
Registered: 8-16-2011
Location: San Nicolas y Lopez Mateos
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 02:11 PM


At this point, I don't think even the Mexican Law Makers know what is what on this issue.
View user's profile
bajagrouper
Senior Nomad
***




Posts: 964
Registered: 8-28-2003
Location: Rincon de Guayabitos, Nayarit, Mexico
Member Is Offline

Mood: happy and retired

[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 02:41 PM


TIP= temporary import permit, it is for tourists entering Mexico on a FMM or visitors permit.

Here in the Puerto Vallarta area Federal Police are checking ex-pats and if they do not have a special letter/permit from customs allowing them 5 days to return the car to the border the federalies are confiscating cars...




I hear the whales song
View user's profile
DENNIS
Platinum Nomad
********




Posts: 29510
Registered: 9-2-2006
Location: Punta Banda
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-13-2013 at 04:39 PM


Quote:
Originally posted by Mula
At this point, I don't think even the Mexican Law Makers know what is what on this issue.




Or many others, for that matter. It remains a "decision for sale" system.
View user's profile
MitchMan
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1855
Registered: 3-9-2009
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 11:44 AM


bajagrouper,
It is my understanding that a TIP on a US plated/registered vehicle owned by holders of FMM, Inmigrante, No-Inmigrante, FM3, FM2, and Residente Temporal visas will enable such visa holders to drive their said vehicles in Prohibited, Free Zone Mexican territory WHICH INCLUDES PUERTO VALLARTA.

Based on the foregoing, it appears that the only confiscations that may be legal police procedure should be limited to those vehicles that are US registered/plated vehicles owned and driven in Puerto Vallarta by Residente Permanente holders or full on Mexican citizens driving such a US registered/plated vehicle. bajagrouper, is this the case? You mentioned that confiscations are occurring in Puerto Vallarta, but you did not define the specific visas that have been the victim of such confiscations. Specifics are crucial.

Thanks in advance, bajagrouper, for any additional light you can provide on the matter.
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
Santiago
Ultra Nomad
*****




Posts: 3502
Registered: 8-27-2003
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 11:56 AM


MM: keep drilling down, I'm very curious on what you find.
How about this:
Husband has an RP and wife a FMM.
Sedan title has both names but their truck is owned by a Calif Corp which in turn is owned jointly by them both.
Based on what you know, what would you advise them to drive?
View user's profile
MitchMan
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1855
Registered: 3-9-2009
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 12:29 PM


Santiago,
How is it that the title has both their names on it but that the corporation owns it? Are you saying that all three own the sedan in some kind of co-tenancy ownership?

I have a similar situation in that my wife and I are co-owners of our US registered/plated truck that is in La Paz. I have RP status and she holds an FMM. One nomad wrote that the FMM holder can definitely drive the vehicle in Baja and the RP holder can drive it while the FMM holder is in the Passenger seat and then went on to say that the RP holder can drive the vehicle while driving alone so long as the RP driver has a written permission to do so signed by the FMM holder/co-owner.

The only thing I am confident of is that my wife, the FMM holder, can drive our truck in Baja. I am not absolutely sure that I can drive it under any circumstances. So, currently, my wife is doing all the driving right now in La Paz.

There are other issues, namely the insurance coverage. I got an annual Qualitas policy through Lewis and Lewis in May 2013 while I was a holder of a No-Inmigrante visa. I called Lewis and Lewis last week to ask if I am covered under the policy with my new RP status and whether or not the policy would be in force if my wife was driving the vehicle. The Lewis and Lewis agent said that my policy was in force because I was not a citizen of Mexico. From her determination, she used the litmus test of whether or not I was a full on Mexican citizen or not. Since the RP status is not Mexican citizenship, then she said I was a tourist/visitor as far as Qualitas's policy coverage was concerned and since my Qualitas policy was for a tourist as opposed to a policy for a Mexican citizen, I was covered as an RP holder with the policy that I obtained in May.

I do not feel comfortable with the Lewis and Lewis litmus test. I do not have confidence that I am covered while I am driving the vehicle. In fact, if the vehicle is stolen, I feel that the insurance company will do everything it can to weasel out of covering the truck by relying on the fact that I am a "permanent" inmigrado and not a temporary tourist. I do not know that as a fact, but I do know that insurance companies will do what ever they can to get out of paying a claim if they can. That goes for all types of insurances. I once took a law class taught by a real estate oriented Judge in Orange County, CA. He said that title insurance policies were so long and hard to read because they were loaded with exceptions to coverage.

With regard to whether or not said policy is in force while my wife drives, the agent said yes and referred me to page 2 of the policy where it states the any driver that has my permission to drive my covered truck is covered by the policy. So, I do feel confident that the policy provides its coverage when my wife drives our truck.

Man, this is a freakin' nightmare.

I am leaving in a couple of weeks, but I will be back in La Paz in October. I plan on renting a car for that trip. I am stalling on my surrendering my RP status in order to get Residente Temporal status because I am waiting to get more reliable feed back on these issues. But, the more I deliberate, I keep coming back to getting Residente Temporal as the solution...but I will hold off a bit more.
I am not any attorney, but I don't have much confidence in what the Lewis and Lewis agent said.

[Edited on 7-14-2013 by MitchMan]
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
chuckie
Elite Nomad
******




Posts: 6082
Registered: 2-20-2012
Location: Kansas Prairies
Member Is Offline

Mood: Weary

[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 02:13 PM


Gets more complicated all the time....



View user's profile
Pescador
Ultra Nomad
*****


Avatar


Posts: 3587
Registered: 10-17-2002
Location: Baja California Sur
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 02:28 PM


Mitchman, I am surprised that someone who is such a stickler for detail would end up in a country like Mexico which is not, nor has ever been known for being detailed about any facet of life. Look at the pages of what went on and all of the interpretations concerning Residente Permanente applications and rules. It is very difficult, if not impossible, to get one government agency, namely immigration, to concur and agree on a new law that was put in to place. Now you expect that the Aduana office is going to understand all of the nuances of Residente Permanente and adjust car issue. I am sure you can go all the way to Mexico City and not get any clearer than you are now.
In my research, I come pretty much to the same conclusion that Lewis and Lewis has shared, that if you get citizenship, the issue is clear, but not so much with the New Residente Permanente.




View user's profile
rts551
Elite Nomad
******




Posts: 6699
Registered: 9-5-2003
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 03:12 PM


Sometimes people will not give up until they get the answer they are looking for.
View user's profile
chuckie
Elite Nomad
******




Posts: 6082
Registered: 2-20-2012
Location: Kansas Prairies
Member Is Offline

Mood: Weary

[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 03:14 PM


Often true....



View user's profile
DENNIS
Platinum Nomad
********




Posts: 29510
Registered: 9-2-2006
Location: Punta Banda
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 03:31 PM


Quote:
Originally posted by rts551
Sometimes people will not give up until they get the answer they are looking for.



Tell 'em what they want to hear, Ralph.....whatever it is. It's the merciful thing to do. :yes:
View user's profile
bajagrouper
Senior Nomad
***




Posts: 964
Registered: 8-28-2003
Location: Rincon de Guayabitos, Nayarit, Mexico
Member Is Offline

Mood: happy and retired

[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 06:07 PM


Quote:
Originally posted by MitchMan
bajagrouper,
It is my understanding that a TIP on a US plated/registered vehicle owned by holders of FMM, Inmigrante, No-Inmigrante, FM3, FM2, and Residente Temporal visas will enable such visa holders to drive their said vehicles in Prohibited, Free Zone Mexican territory WHICH INCLUDES PUERTO VALLARTA.

Based on the foregoing, it appears that the only confiscations that may be legal police procedure should be limited to those vehicles that are US registered/plated vehicles owned and driven in Puerto Vallarta by Residente Permanente holders or full on Mexican citizens driving such a US registered/plated vehicle. bajagrouper, is this the case? You mentioned that confiscations are occurring in Puerto Vallarta, but you did not define the specific visas that have been the victim of such confiscations. Specifics are crucial.

Thanks in advance, bajagrouper, for any additional light you can provide on the matter.


Sorry, I miss read the article, the federales were confiscating cars with "EXPIRED TIP's"...




I hear the whales song
View user's profile
CortezBlue
Super Nomad
****


Avatar


Posts: 2213
Registered: 11-14-2006
Location: Fenix/San Phelipe
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-14-2013 at 08:48 PM


If you received the same letter I did and if you look carefully, it refers to Permanent and Non Permanent card holders. Mine says nothing about car plates or registration of my vehicle.
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
MitchMan
Super Nomad
****




Posts: 1855
Registered: 3-9-2009
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-15-2013 at 09:33 AM


I think that most of you guys have more experience in Baja than I do. Given what is known at this time, what do you guys recommend? In view of your comments, I am open to your take on this.

If you were/are in La Paz today and you have Residente Permanente status today and you only own a US registered/plated 15 year old 4x4 Tacoma blue book valued at $6,500 USD with a Qualitas annual policy first written when you had the Inmigrante status two months ago, and you have a boat and trailer both of which are registered in the USA with a California license plate on the trailer, what would you guys do? All things considered, would YOU drive the car in La Paz or anywhere in the Baja today? Would you pull the boat and trailer with it today?

While there are some unchartered waters, figuratively speaking, with regard to this issue, there is no substitute, in most things, for solid experience, experience that you guys may have.

Honestly, and sincerely, and specifically, what would you guys do, bottom line? I'm not asking you to tell me what to do, nor am I asking you for legal advice, just your honest and sincere opinion as to what you would do today in La Paz in the situation described above? Pescador? rts551? bajagrouper? Dennis? Cortezblue? I've always believed that there is strength in numbers.
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
rts551
Elite Nomad
******




Posts: 6699
Registered: 9-5-2003
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-15-2013 at 09:54 AM


Immigrado for 8 years and never have worried about my cars, boat, quads or trailer. Stopped once in La Paz by Federal Police for registration check on the quads and trailer. No problem. In general I don't think that immigration is an issue in Baja and Baja Sur although some day that may change
View user's profile
CortezBlue
Super Nomad
****


Avatar


Posts: 2213
Registered: 11-14-2006
Location: Fenix/San Phelipe
Member Is Offline


[*] posted on 7-15-2013 at 10:06 AM


I am assuming that the car will be in Mexico permanently?

If that is the case, I would register your vehicle in South Dakota www.claycountysd.org

I would plead ignorance, if that doesn't work there is always modida!!
View user's profile Visit user's homepage
 Pages:  1  

  Go To Top

 






All Content Copyright 1997- Q87 International; All Rights Reserved.
Powered by XMB; XMB Forum Software © 2001-2014 The XMB Group






"If it were lush and rich, one could understand the pull, but it is fierce and hostile and sullen. The stone mountains pile up to the sky and there is little fresh water. But we know we must go back if we live, and we don't know why." - Steinbeck, Log from the Sea of Cortez

 

"People don't care how much you know, until they know how much you care." - Theodore Roosevelt

 

"You can easily judge the character of others by how they treat those who they think can do nothing for them or to them." - Malcolm Forbes

 

"Let others lead small lives, but not you. Let others argue over small things, but not you. Let others cry over small hurts, but not you. Let others leave their future in someone else's hands, but not you." - Jim Rohn

 

"The best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer." - Cunningham's Law







Thank you to Baja Bound Mexico Insurance Services for your long-term support of the BajaNomad.com Forums site.







Emergency Baja Contacts Include:

Desert Hawks; El Rosario-based ambulance transport; Emergency #: (616) 103-0262